Good Readers and Good Writers Authors Tone

The author's tone, or attitude, seems critical and somewhat harsh, although his words are actually informative and direct. He questions the classic works of Jane Austen. He says, "Can we really rely on Jane Austen's picture of landowning England with baronets and landscaped grounds when all she knew was a clergyman's parlor?"( Nabokov 2) He questions a great author who is a significant contributor to the literary field. Not only does Nabokov critique Austen's work, but he also criticizes the author's knowledge. His criticism comes off as very harsh and rude to many readers including me. Vladimir Nabokov, the author, purpose may not have been to criticize others work but it comes off a harsh way. It may take away readers because of critical comments.

The author states repeatedly that the reader should pay attention to detail and re-reading a writing numerous times. (Nabokov 2) It shows the author wants the reader to appreciate the writing. This proves he is informative and direct. Another example of the author being knowledgeable is when he lists the three parts of becoming a great writer; magic, story, and lesson. He goes on to explain why each of these parts helps a person become a great writer. (Nabokov 4) This shows that Nabokov is trying to help people become better writers.

The reader can see that Vladimir Nabokov is a intelligent man with good reading and writing skills. His tone seems critical but after reading the essay more than once the reader can see he is trying to be informative and helpful.

Nabokov, Vladimir. "Good Readers and Good Writers." Lectures on Literature. New York: Plurabelle Books, 1946